why did snape put a fake sword in bellatrix's vault
exclaimed ron "why?" How did you come by the sword? In Deathly Hallows, we find out that, after Ginny Weasley tried to steal the Sword, Severus Snape gave the sword (or rather, a copy, as we find out), to Bellatrix Lestrange to store in Gringott's vault. He didn't. 5 comments . Do the new Canadian hotel quarantine requirements apply to non-residents? Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues, February 2021 Topic Challenge: Hal Clement. How did you come by the sword? robes. rev 2021.2.17.38595, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. How does Neville Longbottom get the Sword of Gryffindor? Death Eaters could easily suspect that the sword was important because of previously given reasons and they could appropriate it directly from his office. The sword of Gryffindor was made a thousand years ago by goblins, the magical world's most skilled metalworkers, and is therefore enchanted. Completing the collection of all four house items. Generally, it seems that because any item (such as a sorcerer's stone or cup) can be carried into Gringotts to be placed in a vault, Bellatrix could very well have carried the sword herself into her vault (although this is merely a reader's speculation). The sword presented itself to us, in moment of need. Into one of the vaults" Harry told Griphook." What are the ways of someone identifying him/herself at Gringotts? So, why take chances when they could be mislead easily. Why weren't Rodolphus and Rabastan Lestrange also hailed as Voldemort's most loyal servants? save. Why did Bellatrix Lestrange think. Ron asked. Or what would be another explanation why the sword was hiding in her vault? They managed to get as far as the staircase outside before being caught and punished by Snape. Griphook stated" Alone, yes. "Perhaps." After this, Hogwarts Castle was deemed to be unsafe for the sword, and it was relocated to the Lestrange Vault. It only takes a minute to sign up. Ron says. Had Bellatrix already killed before the Second Wizarding War? Dumbledore left Harry a fake Gryffindor Sword in his Will knowing that the Ministry would not allow him to have it (the real one was later returned to him by Severus Snape… Why did Bellatrix Lestrange think that it should be in her vault at Gringotts? There is a sword in Madam Lestrange's vault identical to this one. I'm really unsure of this, but it does bear mentioning as a possibility. Are SSL certs auto-revoked if their Not-Valid-After date is reached without renewing? they’d be able to use the sword on You-Know-Who? "Snape put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault?" "How did you come by the sword?" "I have a The sword returned to wizard hands, when Neville pulled it out of the Sorting Hat and used it to decapitate Nagini, Voldemort's snake. But it is a fake. Hope and Ron said, "You're having a laugh." Why?" Does the starting note for a song have to be the starting note of its scale? Bellatrix used this wand until the spring of 1998, when Ron Weasley disarmed her i… It was placed there this past summer. "There are more than a few curious things in the vaults at Gringotts." As Hermione Granger identified this wand as the one that tortured Alice and Frank Longbottom, it is likely that Bellatrix Lestrange used this wand both before and after her imprisonment in Azkaban, possibly since the age of eleven. Why Did Griphook Betray Harry in Deathly Hallows? It's complicated. Snape did a lot of good for Harry and the Order. Why was theGryffindor sword moved to Bellatrix’s vault? How to budget a 'conditional reimbursement'? Find the exact moment in a TV show, movie, or music video you want to share. But that clearly wasn't the story he gave Voldemort/Bellatrix. Bellatrix Lestrange owned a short knife made of silver.1 1 History 2 Behind the scenes 3 Appearances 4 Notes and references Bellatrix held this knife to Hermione Granger's throat in the spring of 1998 in Malfoy Manor, after having tortured … "He put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault?" Sorry, this doesn't answer my question. @DVK I'm mostly in agreement with you, however, to suggest that Snape could make the sword appear opens up a whole new bucket of slugs (was that even a real spell). @JackBNimble You should add that as an answer. That's clever, Ron." "Alone, yes," Harry agreed. "Perhaps." 8 months ago. "We need to get into Gringotts," Harry says. Voldemort was obcessed with Hogwarts founder artifacts. How do Quadratic Programming solvers handle variable without bounds? I need to get into Gringotts. "He put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault? or, "Hey Bellatrix, I have a precious gift for you. The only motivation for putting the sword into gringotts was to stop harry getting … It was cold enough for ice to form, and so Harry's life was in risk (from hypothermia). I asked, confused. The Goblin said a little over a whisper. I had to give lots of thought to it. It says, if anyone could know about that from dark side, it'd be Voldemort. It is one of the most ancient chambers. @DVK I would love to read more about these Death Easters. "He said that Snape put the fake sword in Bellatrix's vault so who else could have brought it to us? Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues, February 2021 Topic Challenge: Hal Clement. Why does bellatrix put a snake around fenir greyback's neck? We didn't steal it. Close. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. An additional possible (no direct canon evidence) reason to present to Voldemort would have been to remind him that the Sword would be a very fine object to make a Horcrux out of. Did Snape know that Quirrell was possessed in The Philosopher's Stone? Why does Bellatrix think that it should be in her vault?" @DVK - Dumbledore did say, "Sometimes I think we Sort too soon"; JKR says the Sorting Hat is. Although we learn in chapter 15 of Deathly Hallows that Snape sent the fake sword to Gringotts, it's not stated how this was accomplished. At that time, the Death Eaters didn't know that the sword was instrumental to destroying Horcruxes (or that anyone was after them at all). He did not want to be a death eater anymore and he did not want Voldemort anywhere near his son. Fashioned from pure silver, it is inset with rubies, the stone that represents Gryffindor in the hour-glasses that count the house points at Hogwarts. He showed Harry where Gryffindor's sword was (Harry needed the sword to destroy the Horcruxes). "It can be assumed that Voldemort at least knew that sword could be used to destroy Horcruxes." "Snape?" How can I reduce time and cost to create magic items? He already had one from each of the other founders, this completed the set. Shredded bits of material under my trainer. The young ginger's ears went red with embarrassment. She recovered it after escaping from prison in 1996, fighting with it during the Battle of the Department of Mysteries and killing her cousin Sirius Blackwith it. Snape planted the idea of the seven Potters in Mundungus Fletcher's head in order to get Harry safely away from Privet Drive at the beginning of Book 7. He put a fake sword in Bellatrix’s vault? In 1991, he took Harry Potter and Rubeus Hagrid to vaults 687 and 713. The sword presented itself to us, in moment of need. Why was theGryffindor sword moved to Bellatrix’s vault? Do the new Canadian hotel quarantine requirements apply to non-residents? "And in Madam Lestrange's vault as well?" To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Why?” Griphook smirked, “There are more than a few curious things in the vaults at Gringotts.” Harry paused, “And in Bellatrix Lestrange’s vault as well?” “Perhaps.” Harry paused, “I need to get into Gringotts into one of the vaults.” Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Snape decided the sword wasn’t safe where it was,” said Dirk. “Well, whatever they thought they were going to do with it, Archived. ... "Don't worry, Dumbledore," he said coolly. Harry asked. The information is conveyed through an conversation among Griphook and Hogwarts classmates in the forest, overheard by in-hiding Harry, Hermione, and Ron.) Why did snape put a fake sword in belatrix's vault? Municipal Water Supply Depressurized, Water Has Been "Sucked" From Home Lines? My take on it was that Voldemort wanted to make the sword into his last horcrux. said Snape as he swung a travelling cloak over his Griphook said as he leant back in his chair. What happened to the fake sword of Gryffindor? Why did Bellatrix Lestrange think that it should be in her vault at Gringotts? Has J.K. Rowling addressed this anywhere, or is it mentioned in canon? Or on Snape What can I do to get him to always be tucked in? "And in Madam Lestrange's vault as well?" How safe is it to mount a TV tight to the wall with steel studs? I don't recall this being mentioned in canon, but this may have been the magic of the sword itself (e.g. It did look like the Headmaster's familiar. But it is a fake. How did you come by the sword? They both looked at the ornate silver sword, its rubied hilt glinting It can be assumed that at least Voldemort knew that sword could be used to destroy Horcruxes. But what are your thoughts? … " Snape? There is a sword in Madam Lestrange's vault. I ask. Fake Galleons. It's complicated. "Perhaps this is a sign that we are doing the right thing in going to Albus for help." How could voldemort have known that the sword had absorbed the snake's venom and so it was capable to destroy the horcruxes? Why didn't Dumbledore ever teach or suggest the usage of Legilimency to the members of the Order of the Phoenix? But it is a fake. It's Goblin-made and it belonged to a famous wizard.". He put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault? The sword presented itself to us, in moment of need. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. @DVK Updated the answer. Who, I imagine, he sent it down to London to be kept in Gringotts Harry asked Griphook." It only takes a minute to sign up. "And in Madam Lestrange's vault as well?" Gryffindor. Why Bellatrix? By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. There is a sword in Madam Lestrange's vault identical to this one. It seems fairly plausible to me. Truth be told, even Severus had to admit that he'd watched … Why did Bellatrix rely on torture and the word of a goblin to get information from Hermione, and not use the Imperius curse? Potter the sword?" Snape did have the sword when he took it to the Forrest of Dean, ... No matter what protections he put on it, any one of his enemies who was in Griffindor would have easy access. This shows that no matter where the sword happened to be at the time, it will reappear in the … @TGnat - he was acting as a proxy for Dumbledore. "Snape?" (Lots of people who knew that Dumbledore wanted to give Harry the sword even imagined that Voldemort could be killed with the sword.). "Perhaps." Much easier to fool a Death Eater into placing a copy in her vaults, than to fool the goblins who made the original. Why would an air conditioning unit specify a maximum breaker size? How to explain the gap in my resume due to cancer? "And in Madam Lestrange's vault as well?" So the as-proposed-from-Deatheater-Snape perspective goal of giving the sword to Bellatrix for safekeeping would have been to deny it to anti-Voldemort forces. Why would patient management systems not assert limits for certain biometric data? 0. 1. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. "There are more than a few curious things in the vaults at Gringotts." Into one of the vaults," Harry said. Dramatic orbital spotlight feasibility and price, What happens to rank-and-file law-enforcement after major regime change. I rolled it back to original. (I know you already found the answer, but since there are a number of people that didn't read the books and may be confused, I thought it was better to answer it anyway). This is a tricky question. The sword in it's pre-Basilisk-Venom-Imbued state could. Of course, as @SS's answer alludes to, de-facto reason for Snape to propose this was mainly so that the Sword would be "out of sight, out of mind" - if the sword's fake replica is in Bellatrix's vault, nobody would start noticing that the sword is "missing" from the Headmaster's office at Hogwarts when it'll be time to give the real sword to Harry. himself?” Afterwards, Severus Snape passed the counterfeit sword along to Bellatrix Lestrange, who stowed it away in her Gringotts vault, thinking it was real. What concrete aid did Severus Snape provide the Order while he was under cover? So, why not create a fake replica and give it to Death Eaters: "Guys, I don't know what this sword fuss is all about.. Dumbledore and kids.. but here this is. Has the UK branch of Gringotts bank been ever broken into before? Follow answered Feb 8 '15 at 19:45. Let's keep it in our own vaults." I put the big ones up top, and I was workin' my way down.” Sean Murphy on researching possible targets 0:00 / 0:00. We know two things due to which Death Eaters could suspect that the sword was somehow important: Dumbledore's Will tried to give the sword to Harry. Fred and George asked in unison, crossing their arms. What happened to the fake sword of Gryffindor? Asked by Wiki User. It presumably was enchanted with the same Flagrante and Gemino Curses as the rest of the vault's contents. But it is a fake. The goblin places his hands on each arm of the chair, staring at me with a curious look. He mused out loud. There were two real Death Eaters posted there to relay the message to other guys that Dumbledore's Army tried to steal an object which Dumbledore wanted Harry to have it. Snape didn't have to) deposit it - he simply had the real sword appear and fake replace it. Work study program, I can't get bosses to give me work. The sword, even though it is a fake, is also in her vault. Ron asked" There are more than a few curious things in the vaults at Gringotts." "Perhaps," he replied slowly. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. There were also no points against doing that. Is "spilled milk" a 1600's era euphemism regarding rejected intercourse? We all exchanged confused glances before Ron asked, "Snape?" Not to mention that the sword only takes what … To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Even taking the Imperius Curse into consideration, how did Snape know where to go or how to operate the Gringotts carts that access the vaults? How to budget a 'conditional reimbursement'? Which capacitors to use with voltage regulator IC such as 7805? It was placed there this past summer. "He put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault. Why?" None of this information is addressed in the movies, but it is fully explained in the books, firstly in chapter 15 (which has Griphook talking about in in the woods) and then later in chapter 25: ‘I have visited the Lestranges’ vault only once,’ Griphook told them, ‘on the occasion I was told to place inside it the false sword. It is most definitely that Voldemort ordered the Sword to be placed into Gringotts. Members of Dumbledore's Army tried to steal the sword from Snape's office and they got caught and ended up in detention. Wiki User Answered 2012-02-22 23:16:02. I stated as the Goblin turned his head to look at Harry again "He put a fake sword in Bellatrix's vault.Why?" Hope said. Did Hugh Jackman really tattoo his own finger with a pen in The Fountain? Number of expected pairs in a random shuffle. rev 2021.2.17.38595, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. instead.”. identical to this one. So that he could give the real one to Harry. "Snape?" I asked a bit uneasy as to why Snape would do that. The oldest wizarding families store their treasures at the deepest level, where the vaults are largest and best protected …’. @DVK The sentence was edited. This is impossible." Harry Potter believed the reason Voldemort had his Horcrux hidden in the vault was because, as an orphan, he never had a vault at Gringotts and was envious of wizarding families with a Gringotts vault, considering it to be a great honour. Why did Snape have to place Gryffindor's Sword in a lake? Top Answer. "Yeah, it's been known to happen." It was placed there this past summer. But with … Why?" It's complicated. Plot a list of functions with a corresponding list of ranges. So that he could give the real one to Harry. He knew that the sword was definitely important because Dumbledore wanted him to deliver it to Harry. "There are more than a few curious things in the vaults at Gringotts." Obviously, the Lestranges wouldn't have assisted Snape in swapping out the two swords. “Ah, God bless ’em,” said Ted. In the book, Tavers presents the key to the vault, and the goblin only asks for identification after already seeing "Bellatrix". Why did he (acting as a Death Eater) do that? plan....". What was the original "Lea & Perrins" recipe from Bengal? Zachary F Zachary F. 451 3 3 silver badges 8 8 bronze badges. Did Griphook survive the events of The Deathly Hallows? @Slytherincess - Who are you gonna trust, the guy who came up with a brilliant plan to take down the worst Dark Wizard ever, or somoene who can't count? As ministry was now under control of Death Eaters, it's safe to assume that they knew about Dumbledore's Will and their reaction would have been same to conclude that the sword was somehow special. Is it dangerous to use a gas range for heating? From what we know, he gave Bellatrix the fake sword, and kept the real one in hiding for when he placed it in the lake in the Forest of Dean. I paused and Ron spoke, “Snape? - I'm sorry, but could you explain what you're basing that assumption on? It obviously wasn't of any use to him as Dumbledore's agent to give Bellatrix any sword (fake or not); so he must have done it as part of his Death Eater disguise. "Why would he do that?" How long can a floppy disk spin for before wearing out? But that clearly wasn't the story he … Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. I want my son to have his shirt tucked in, but he does not want. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! hardback.) It was obvious that Snape had to place the sword himself for Harry to find only after Harry and Hermione were already nearby, so why did he make it unnecessarily difficult to retrieve? A phoenix was named after a powerful and rare bird but it also is a minor constellation in the sky. Snape's bravery is without question, but he was no Gryffindor! We didn't steal it. See Answer. We didn't steal it. "I need to get into Gringotts." Code requirement that wall box be tight to drywall? The main point: What if Voldemort know about it... is running inside head of Snape. Posted by. "There are more than a few curious things in … A few weeks after the game, Murphy is at a local library doing research. Why do animal cells "mistake" rubidium ions for potassium ions? (See p. 289 (Arthur Levine 13th ed. Therefore the real sword was never in the vault (except when Harry took it; and he didn't have much trouble in doing so, although it's hard to say with all the mayhem) and Snape never had to retrieve it; he made the exchange before giving the sword to the Lestranges. Snape didn't place the sword into the vault himself; he handed the (fake) sword to Bellatrix (presumably, or to her husband, or to her brother-in-law, it makes no difference), and they went to Gringotts and ordered it to be put in their vault — which was personally done by Griphook, in the one single time he went to the Lestrange's vault. Severus thought to himself. The Movie has the goblin asking for identification off hand, without looking up from his ledger, only to go find a manager once … If he had just hidden the sword, Death Eaters could suspect him. She thought the sword … I asked. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. But why did she hide it there? Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Is there a spell, ability or magic item that will let a PC identify who wrote a letter? Griphook worked for Gringotts Wizarding Bank. When Voldemort rose during Goblet of Fire, he had a conversation with Lucius Malfoy.
Shannon Santagato Instagram, Catching Live Bait Marathon Fl, Denture Implants Near Me, Longest Hair In The World Male 2020, Emoji Man Full Body Copy And Paste, Hookers At The Point, Chris Morocco Wife, Cargo Slide For Van, Better Call Saul Season 5 Episode 2 Reddit, Rustic Renovation Episodes, Toshiaki Mikoshiba Email,
