canik tp9sfx vs glock 17
Covering a wide spectrum of performance and price, both pistols shot Hotshot Elite 115gr FMJ and Winchester NATO-Spec 124gr FMJ ammunition. Like parts from cz custom or Cajun gun works. This effectively made these two handguns equal in terms of shootability and ergonomics, with a fraction of an advantage given to the TP9SA. Accuracy wasn't tremendously different from the two pistols, though the TP9SA had a slight performance edge with Winchester NATO-spec 124gr +P, making it more appropriate for competition use. By deduction, we can approximate the human error outside of the Ransom Rest following the controlled testing. It deviates from it by incorporating a push-button magazine release, alternate grip profile and de-cocking button on the slide. CANIK TP9 Elite SC, Semi-automatic Pistol, Striker Fired 9mm, 3.6" Barrel, Polymer Frame, Black Finish, Micro Red-Dot Base Plate, Holster & 2 Interchangeable … Considering that I already had the Walther, picking up that Canik just has me going "I paid $300 more for that Walther". A LOT of thought went into the TP9SFX package, this particular SKU being the one that includes the Vortex Viper red dot sight. Glock 17 vs. Canik TP9SA: Polymer Pistol Showdown It's the Glock 17 vs. Canik TP9SA in this polymer pistol showdown. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. HK's new VP9L OR is the long-slide, optics-ready pistol VP9 fans have been waiting for. Not because it’s the best comparison I could do, but because it’s the semi-auto handgun that I shoot the most, and is the closest thing in my collection (prior to getting the TP9SFX) to compare the Canik to. That's a lot of value added in such a small package. The Walther CCP M2 in .380 is one of the great all-around defensive pistols on the market, and the fact that it is so easy to operate and shoot makes it a great all-around gun for just about anybody. Calling the Glock successful is like referring to Bill Gates as "well off." Use load data at your own risk. Shooting the Canik has been awesome- I can’t think of any other way to say it. Dawson Precision sights are pretty cool on this, but I'm looking to set it up with an RMR. While both handguns are excellent examples of modern polymer-framed pistol design, one must be better than the other. The threaded barrel, Picatinny-style accessory rail, ambidextrous safety, ambidextrous magazine release and three (3) 16rd magazines come standard. Here we go! ... it doesn't get any better than the Canik TP9SFX. I can’t wait! A pistol isn't worth its weight in brass if it patterns like a cylinder bore shotgun. Turn your Walther PPQ into a match-ready Q5 with a simple parts swap. And that “seed” grew into this story- an in-depth review of the Canik TP9SFX and a comparison to my customized Glock 17. $36.99 MSRP. Here’s a quick comparison of the two pistols (features and specs): For the money, the Canik is hard to beat here! I’ve fed hollowpoints, round nose bullets, and flat-point bullets throuh the Canik, and it just “eats them up”. To this day, it remains one of the most reliable handguns ever built, and largely because of its reliability, it also remains one of the most popular. The TP9SFX also points much more naturally for me than the Glock. I don’t plan to let go of my Glock 17 any time soon, but I’m sure it will see a lot less trigger time. Finally, while the Glock shot the best individual group (0.9″ with Federal 115 grain factory ammo), the Canik shot groups averaging 6.36% tighter compared to the Glock 17. Find out whether the ubiquitous Glock stays on top or is knocked off by the TP9SA. A firearm’s bore and chamber are critical to how the gun will function and how difficult it will be to clean (copper and carbon fouling). The latter of these is a superfluous remnant of its double, single-action progenitor, the TP9. A cursory search of popular video-hosting sites and gun blogs reveals countless torture tests having little to no effect on the Glock. Above: the moment the bullet leaves the barrel, captured with a high-speed camera shooting at 4,456 fps. Here, I’ve taken all of the shots fired, and averaged all of the data: Remember the fact that the Canik barrel is 20% longer in the “business department”? Your email address will not be published. The point being, few firearms can hope to approach the ubiquity of Gaston Glock's namesake pistol. Since this aspect ties into felt recoil and is directly related to both shooter experience and hand-size, three different shooters tested the gun. Follow @UReloader Self-Defense: How to Search for Additional Threats, Compact Carry Pistols Are Effective With Practice, Practice the X Drill to Reinforce Pistol Skills: Here's How, 6 Best Compact High-Capacity 9mm Handguns, CZ 75 B 45th Anniversary Special Edition Pistol, Glock 17 vs. Canik TP9SA: Polymer Pistol Showdown, KelTec P17 22LR Pistol – Feature Packed, Accurate & Fun to Shoot, Pistol Skills Drills - Hardball's Headache. Rather than speculate over which is superior, these two polymer-framed pistols will be compared and contrasted across three crucial elements of design and three economic factors. TESTED: Canik TP9SFX Pistol In-Depth and Comparison to Glock 17, this particular SKU being the one that includes the Vortex Viper red dot sight, https://freedomsmith.com/shop?olsPage=t%2Fracer-style-triggers-for-canik-sfx-sfl-and-sf-only&page=3, http://taylorfreelancestore.com/canik-backstrap-brass-cerakoted-tungsten/, Subscribe to Ultimate Reloader Reloading Blog by Email, Reloading 7.62x39mm with Berry’s 123 grain Bullets, TESTED: Lapua 6.5 Creedmoor Brass (Large and Small Primer), My Most Sensitive Scale: AND EJ-54D2 (0.003 grains), TESTED: Winchester StaBALL 6.5 Creedmoor-Class Powder, Learn From the Best: Rifle Building Class with Gordy Gritters, Unsolved: 44 Magnum Over-Pressure Mystery, RCBS Lock-Out Die Part II: Setup and Maintenance, RCBS Lock-Out Die Part I: Theory of Operation, Reloading Safety: Powder Check Systems Overview. Thankfully the Canik TP9SA is based on an already-proven design: the Walther P99. And now I’m really looking forward to gettting an action shooting pistol range setup, and to make progress towards competing. We think the Canik TP9SFX is a bargain and it even snuck on to our list of the best full size 9mm pistols for sale in 2019. Will this cause the chamber to be more difficult to clean? With similar-length barrels and locking mechanisms, the two pistols produced very similar velocities from the same cartridges. What’s really impressive is how Canik designed the case to provide a secure spot for everything listed above. If only I had unlimited time and resources! I think the Canik TP9SFX trigger is great, but not perfect. It:s very accurate. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets. If you want to get your own TP9SFX, you can get a great deal at Palmetto State Armory, click here: Do you have a Canik TP9SFX? Objectively, the Glock has a larger, wider grip. https://cajungunworks.com/product/2389/ Hold that thought, I’ll come back to this later! Jump to Latest Follow ... Got rid of a Glock 34 MOS because I just didn't get along with it. Let’s compare this to two Glock triggers that I tested: (my stock Glock 20, and my customized Glock 17: click/tap to enlarge), What’s interesting here is how the Canik TP9SFX pretty much splits the difference between the peak force for a factory Glock trigger, and a Glock with 3.5 lb disconnector and other enhancements. Unfortunately, with similar size, weight and identical magazine capacities, the only deciding factors are either situational or subjective. A few months ago I competed in a “mostly rifle” match called the Findlay Cup. This will display all compatible magazines with your specific Canik model ** ... TP9SFX (3) TP9SFL (3) TP9SFT (3) Sort By. Right now, no fewer than four companies are currently producing magazines for Glock pistols. Why? That said, both the medium and small-handed shooters found the controls inaccessible without shifting their firing grip. Still, the edge goes to the Canik here as you’d expect. The bane of new designs is aftermarket parts since most companies that produce them only want to do so for established, popular products. One such new attempt is the Turkish-made, Century-imported, TP9SA in 9mm parabellum. So my local gun dealer started ordering these Canik guns The last, myself, is five foot, nine inches and 155 lbs. I love Glocks, and they work really good for me. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G17 and Canik TP9SFx The affordable price, reliability and shootability of the Taurus G3c make it a perfect choice... Handguns Digital Staff - September 13, 2019. Go with a SIG full size SS guide rod, or Glock extended tungsten rod, I have both. What I have learned is that if you want to shoot loads in the 125 to 130 PF you will need to change out the guide rod to a Sig 320 one piece and a commander spring from the 15 to 13 pound with a Glock 6 pound striker spring. But you rarely see these “internals” – let’s take a look at the Canik TP9SFX chamber and bore using the Lyman Borecam, starting with the chamber! This type of surface finish would be typical for mid-grade guns, but less frequently found with more expensive firearms. Here’s the overall barrel length comparison: Comparing the lengths of the rifled portions of the barrels: That’s a difference of about 0.71″, making the Canik barrel approximately 20% longer in the “business portion” of the bore. So I had to find out “the complete story” for the Canik TP9SFX trigger by putting it on the TriggerScan. The Hardball's Headache pistol drill is very similar to the El Presidente drill with a higher level of difficulty due to two added twists. Calling the Glock successful is like referring to Bill Gates as "well off." Poll: Where are you finding reloading primers and powder? July 24, 2019 Gavin Reloading Blog, Ultimate Gun Reviews 9mm parabellum, Canik TP9SFX, Glock 17, Glock 34, Reloading, Reloading Blog, Reloading Press, Reloading Videos, Ultimate Gun Reviews, Ultimate Reloader. The TP9SA, on the other hand was found to have perfectly accessible controls to all shooters. I have the Canik TP9SFx and highly recommend it. I’ll have to say, it doesn’t really feel that heavy- but numbers don’t lie in this case! Shooters who like their dedicated bedside gun to have five magazines, custom sights or to act as a suppressor host will find the Glock 17 a better fit. MA904. Posted by 3 days ago. If a firearm isn't dependable, then it is almost immediately doomed to failure from its inception. Magazine, 9mm . Shooting 145g ACME over 3.1g TG with COL 1.135. It’s got great balance, great ergonomics (the pre-installed bacstrap fits my hand perfectly), and most importantly- I can get shots on target easily. However, that hasn't stopped many from trying. Both handguns were tested with a combination of plinking and defensive ammunition. Poll: What Rifle Cartridge Do You Reload Most Often? The Canik Tp9SFX has the best striker fired trigger out of the box. Glock MOS & Canik TP9SFX So not only has Glock STILL not figured out the importance of co-witness irons for their newly released G17 and G19 MOS models, Canik has proudly launched an optics ready version of their TP9 pistol on which its impossible even to install aftermarket suppressor sights - because the rear sight is built into the plate that is removed to … With standard features like multiple adapter plates for mounting most any reflex sight, adjustable magazine and ambidextrous charging handle for the quickest reload on the firing line, and Warren Tactical sights, the TP9SFx is your quickest route to the medal stand. There are aftermarket parts available to spiffy it up if that's your thing. However, the TP9SA's aggressively checkered backstrap dug into the small tester's hands during extended shooting sessions. Canik TP9SF Elite 9mm Black w/ Holster and 2 Mags - $429.99. I have tried several other striker-fired polymer pistols. I really had fun shooting steel with the Glock, and that planted the seed: I didn’t know it at the time, but I’d have to get a competition-style pistol before long. ... #17 • Jan 28, 2018. 4.3OZ 60/40 COMBED RINGSPUN COTTON/POLYESTER I’ll note here that I’m new to “action shooting”, and I do hope to compete in a pistol match at some point. Poll: What Progressive Reloading Press Do You Use Most? One is over six feet tall, weighing around 275 pounds, another is five feet, four inches tall and 90 pounds. The problem being that some products can't become popular without that support. It really is a great design improvement over the Canik TP9SFx which I mentioned earlier. That includes a Glock 17L, a Glock 34, a Springfield XDm full-size match. Canik TP9SFX: 5.200″ overall length (Glock 34 long slide has 5.31″ overall barrel length) Comparing the lengths of the rifled portions of the barrels: Glock 17: ~3.54″ Canik TP9SFX: ~4.250″ That’s a difference of about 0.71″, making the Canik barrel approximately 20% longer in the “business portion” of the bore. Here’s the data: The Remington 124 grain UMC ammunition shot well in both guns, here’s the data: The data above is for two groups fired for each type of ammunition in each gun. The Canik TP9SFx is a 5" knockoff of the Walther PPQ. I got my Glock 17 from a friend who had modified the trigger (Ghost 3.5lb disconnnector and a bunch of other enhancements), installed an extended slide release, fitted an oversize magazine catch, and upgraded to aftermarket sights. Extra parts and tools (white translucent case) includes: Comes with industry standard dovetail sight cuts that are compatible with a large variety of aftermarket sights (front sight cut: M&P, rear sight cut: Glock 34), Warren Tactical sights with red and green fiber optic front sight, Removeable Red Dot cover – Rear sight installed in cover to eliminate interference with certain Red Dot sights, Improved single action trigger with claimed 3.5 – 4 lb. You can see it on the graph, but it’s not overly noticeable when you actually pull the trigger- most likely because the peak force actuation is smooth, as evidenced on the graph. Out of stock | Add to Compare; TP9 Series 10 rd. The last thing shooters should consider when deciding between two products is aftermarket support. Don’t miss out on Ultimate Reloader updates, make sure you’re subscribed! NICE REVIEW! CZ P10S 9mm Flat Dark Earth w/ Night Sights - $599.99. At less than 14 ounces fully loaded, and barely longer than a dollar bill, the P17 is concealable for pretty much anyone. The TP9SFX is by far the “most complete turn-key handgun package” I’ve ever owned. GLOCK RUGER SMITH & WESSON SIG SAUER REMINGTON. Might be an interesting follow-up! ** Select your Canik firearm on the left-hand side of the page. As an active shooter who owns and loves all 3 guns, I can point out a few comparisons for you: 1) the Canik has a 5.2" barrel, providing you slightly more accurate shooting than the M&P 5" barrel; 2) the Canik mags hold 20-rounds vs the M&P mags hold 17-rounds; 3) the Canik trigger feels 1-1.5 lbs lighter than the M&P 2.0 trigger. Again, I would wonder how this might change after the Canik has fired thousands of rounds… These pistols are close in terms of results, but the brand new Canik here beat the well-used Glock across the board. The Canik TP9SFX is a decent pistol. If you get Glock knuckle, you might have the same thing with this firearm. The next category to consider is accuracy. Either which one feels best to the perfective shooter, or how much gun-specific gear they intend to purchase. Possibly, but it’s not likely to be noticeable. Jim and Rich cover the benefits and the challenges presented by very small pistols. Canik TP9SFX 9mm Black - $539.99. Ultimate Reloader LLC is not responsible for errors in load data on this website. It’s also interesting to note that there’s really no grittiness with the Glock triggers. No misfires, jams, magazine issues, or any other issues. While this is a good step in the right direction, the TP9SA will have to stick around for at least a decade to reach Glock-levels of market saturation. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G17 Gen5 and Canik TP9SF Elite Those not invested in a pistol platform that want an affordable, reliable handgun in a common, inexpensive caliber that ships with enough gear for the average shooter will find the TP9SA an attraction option. I’ll admit, when I was asked to compare the Gen4 Glock 19 and the Canik TP9SF Elite in the context of “EDC” guns I didn’t expect any surprises. I have both a TP9SFX and a g17. Set ... TP9 Elite SC 17 rd Magazine W/Grip Extension, 9mm . ... 17. Galloway Precision offers springs and a cheaper trigger for it. That tells me that most of the energy is used by the time the bullets leaves the Glock 17’s bore. Massive advantage goes to the Glock. The TP9SFx is designed for competitive shooting right out of the box. https://freedomsmith.com/shop?olsPage=t%2Fracer-style-triggers-for-canik-sfx-sfl-and-sf-only&page=3 This makes it inappropriate for smaller-handed shooters. All Handguns subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. The Canik is a better gun out of the box hands down. 'http':'https';if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src=p+'://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js';fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document, 'script', 'twitter-wjs'); © 2021 Copyright 2016 Ultimate Reloader LLC. FN will get this gun right and this looks like it will turn out to be FN’s most cost-effective handgun to date. The Canik barrel is very similar to the Glock 17 barrel overall, here they are side-by-side: (click/tap to enlarge). With a Ransom Rest, we can measure (directly, and by the process of elimination) factors 2 and 3 above, leaving the human element as the “remainder” of the error.
Lube Oil Analysis Parameters, Cuenca Ecuador Crime, Lg Up875 Firmware Update, Bailey Bridge Uk, Dark Chestnut Log Ffxiv, County Comm Knives, Anime Script Example, Dried Anchovies Malaysia, Wolf Pack Quotev, Açelya Ozcan Biography,
